Skip to main content

Independent Reviews Are Changing to Independent Evaluations: What Registered Clubs Need to Know

The 2026 AML/CTF reforms have changed how registered clubs must independently assess their anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing programs. 

For many years, registered clubs operating gaming machines have been familiar with the requirement to undertake an independent review of their AML/CTF program. 

However, changes introduced on 31 March 2026 have replaced the previous independent review requirements with a new requirement for an independent evaluation. 

While the change in terminology may seem relatively minor, the scope, frequency, and reporting requirements differ in important ways that clubs need to understand. 

Importantly, the changes reinforce the need for clubs to demonstrate that their AML/CTF programs are not simply documented but are implemented and effectively manage their money laundering, terrorism financing, and proliferation financing risks. 

What Has Changed? 

Under the previous AML/CTF framework, independent reviews focused on Part A of the club’s AML/CTF program. 

These reviews assessed whether the club had appropriate measures in place to identify, manage and mitigate money laundering and terrorism financing risks. 

Independent reviewers were also expected to test whether the program was being implemented and followed. 

Under the revised requirements, the independent evaluation applies to the entire AML/CTF program, including the club’s risk assessment, AML/CTF policies and their implementation. 

The revised approach explicitly requires evaluators to assess three key areas: 

  • Risk assessment: Has the club appropriately identified and assessed the money laundering, terrorism financing and proliferation financing risks associated with its operations?
  • Policy design: Do the club’s AML/CTF policies meet the requirements of the legislation and appropriately manage its identified risks?
  • Implementation and effectiveness: Are the club’s systems, procedures and controls being followed, and are they effectively managing the identified risks?

This broader evaluation gives clubs, senior management and boards a more complete assessment of their AML/CTF compliance arrangements. 

From Independent Review to Independent Evaluation 

Previous independent review New independent evaluation 
Focused on Part A of the AML/CTF program Covers the entire AML/CTF program 
Examined risk management and implementation Explicitly evaluates risk assessment, policy design and the effectiveness of controls 
Frequency was risk-based, with AUSTRAC recommending reviews every 2–3 years for high-risk businesses Must occur at least every 3 years, subject to transitional arrangements 
Findings informed compliance improvements Written findings must be provided to the governing body and responsible senior managers 
Clubs were expected to address identified deficiencies Clear requirements apply to reviewing adverse findings and updating risk assessments and policies where required 

The important distinction is not that previous independent reviews were simply paperwork exercises. AUSTRAC already expected independent reviewers to test systems and controls. 

The new requirements provide a broader, clearer framework for assessing the entire AML/CTF program. 

What Will an Independent Evaluation Look Like in a Registered Club? 

An independent evaluation should be tailored to the club’s size, complexity, and risks. 

For example, an evaluator may examine how the club manages risks associated with: 

  • Cash being inserted into electronic gaming machines with minimal gameplay.
  • Customers repeatedly redeeming credits or using cash redemption terminals (CRTs).
  • Multiple transactions that may indicate attempts to avoid identification or reporting requirements.
  • Customer identification and verification requirements.
  • Transaction monitoring and unusual customer behaviour.
  • Suspicious matter reporting and internal escalation procedures.
  • Enhanced customer due diligence for higher-risk customers.
  • AML/CTF training and staff awareness.
  • Oversight by senior management and the board.

Rather than simply confirming that the club has a procedure for identifying suspicious transactions, the evaluator may examine actual transactions and speak with gaming employees to understand how that procedure is being implemented. 

A practical example 

Consider a club that has a documented procedure requiring gaming employees to report unusual customer behaviour to the AML/CTF Compliance Officer. 

During the independent evaluation, the evaluator may ask: 

  • Do gaming employees understand what unusual behaviour looks like?
  • Are employees reporting incidents to the Compliance Officer?
  • Are these reports being documented?
  • Does the Compliance Officer investigate and assess reported concerns?
  • Are decisions about suspicious matter reports appropriately recorded?
  • Is management monitoring whether the process is effective?

A club may have an excellent written procedure, but if employees are unaware of it or do not follow it, the control may not be effective. 

This is one of the key issues an independent evaluation is designed to identify. 

How Often Must a Club Conduct an Independent Evaluation? 

Under the revised legislation, independent evaluations must be conducted at least once every three years. 

However, the frequency must also be appropriate to the nature, size and complexity of the club. 

For example, a large club operating numerous gaming machines, handling substantial cash transactions or operating across multiple venues may determine that more frequent evaluations are appropriate. 

AUSTRAC expects clubs to document why they have selected their evaluation frequency. 

Transitional arrangements for existing clubs 

Importantly, AUSTRAC has introduced transitional arrangements for the first independent evaluation under the new framework. 

For existing reporting entities that were enrolled with AUSTRAC on 30 March 2026 and had already completed at least one independent review under the previous requirements, the first independent evaluation must be completed by the later of: 

  • Four years after the most recent independent review; or
  • 31 March 2027.

Example 1: A club completed its previous independent review on 1 August 2024. Under the transitional arrangements, its first independent evaluation would be due by 1 August 2028. 

Example 2: A club completed its previous independent review on 15 February 2023. Its first independent evaluation would be due by 31 March 2027. 

These transitional arrangements provide existing clubs with additional time to transition to the new evaluation requirements. 

Clubs should confirm their individual deadline rather than automatically scheduling their next evaluation three years after their previous review. 

Once the first evaluation is complete, the ongoing evaluation schedule must comply with the revised requirements. 

Who Can Conduct an Independent Evaluation? 

AUSTRAC allows independent evaluations to be conducted by a suitably independent person from within or outside the organisation. 

However, the evaluator must have sufficient knowledge of the AML/CTF obligations applying to the club and the money laundering and terrorism financing risks associated with the registered club industry. 

Importantly, the evaluator must not have been responsible for developing, implementing or maintaining the AML/CTF program, systems and controls being evaluated. 

This means the club’s AML/CTF Compliance Officer would not be considered sufficiently independent to evaluate their own program. 

Similarly, a consultant who developed and maintains the club’s AML/CTF program would generally not be sufficiently independent to conduct its independent evaluation. 

No mandatory professional qualifications are prescribed for independent evaluators, but clubs should carefully consider their experience, industry knowledge, and ability to objectively assess compliance. 

The aim is to obtain an objective assessment, not simply confirmation that the club has the required documents. 

What Happens After the Evaluation? 

Under the revised requirements, the independent evaluator must prepare a written report documenting their findings. 

This report must be provided to the club’s governing body, generally the board, and any senior manager responsible for approving the AML/CTF program. 

The report should explain what was evaluated, how the evaluation was undertaken, what records or transactions were tested, and any identified deficiencies. 

Where adverse findings are identified, the club must review its relevant risk assessment or AML/CTF policies and make updates where required. 

For example, an evaluation might identify that the club has inadequate procedures for monitoring repeated cash redemptions. 

In response, the club may need to: 

  • Review the risks associated with cash redemptions.
  • Update its transaction monitoring procedures.
  • Provide additional training to gaming employees.
  • Implement appropriate monitoring or reporting controls.
  • Check whether those improvements are working.

Where the club updates its risk assessment or AML/CTF policies, those changes must be documented within 14 days. 

The club should also maintain evidence of how findings were considered, what actions were taken, who was responsible and whether those actions were effective. 

The board’s responsibility 

An independent evaluation is not simply a report for the Compliance Officer. 

It provides the board and senior management with important information about how effectively the club is meeting its AML/CTF obligations. 

Boards should ensure that evaluation findings are considered, corrective actions are assigned, and progress is monitored. 

Receiving the report is only one part of effective governance. Addressing identified weaknesses is equally important. 

What About Smaller Clubs With 15 or Fewer Gaming Machines? 

A separate statutory exemption applies to eligible small gaming venues with entitlements to operate no more than 15 gaming machines. 

Under section 233K of the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006, clubs that meet all relevant eligibility conditions are exempt from Part 1A of the Act, including the AML/CTF program and independent evaluation requirements. 

However, the exemption is conditional, including restrictions relating to related entities and the types of designated services provided. 

Eligible clubs must continue meeting their remaining AML/CTF obligations, including applicable suspicious matter reporting requirements. 

Clubs should confirm their eligibility before relying on this exemption. 

What Should Registered Clubs Do Now? 

Registered clubs should use the changes as an opportunity to assess whether their AML/CTF arrangements are both compliant and effective. 

Five practical actions are recommended: 

  • Confirm your evaluation deadline. Identify when your last independent review was completed and determine whether the transitional arrangements apply.
  • Update your AML/CTF program. Ensure your policies refer to independent evaluations and explain their frequency, scope, evaluator selection and reporting requirements.
  • Review your risk assessment. Confirm that it reflects the club’s current gaming operations, customer behaviour, products, services and delivery channels.
  • Maintain evidence of implementation. Keep appropriate records of training, transaction monitoring, internal reviews, customer due diligence, compliance reporting and board oversight.
  • Prepare for the evaluation. Select an appropriately qualified and independent evaluator who understands registered clubs and can provide practical recommendations.

Regular internal compliance monitoring remains important. An independent evaluation does not replace the club’s ongoing responsibility to review its risks, follow its AML/CTF policies and address compliance issues as they arise. 

Final Thoughts: Compliance Is About More Than Documentation 

The transition from independent reviews to independent evaluations reinforces an important principle for registered clubs. 

Having an AML/CTF program is one thing. 

Demonstrating that it works is another. 

Clubs should not view an independent evaluation as an administrative exercise to be completed at least every three years. 

It is an opportunity to get an objective assessment of the club’s financial crime risks, confirm whether its controls are effective, and identify areas for improvement. 

For CEOs, boards and AML/CTF Compliance Officers, the message is straightforward: 

Understand your risks, implement your controls, maintain evidence and act on the findings. 

That is how registered clubs can move beyond simply having an AML/CTF program to demonstrating effective compliance. 

References 

  • AUSTRAC — Step 5: Conduct an independent evaluation.
  • AUSTRAC — AML/CTF Transitional Rules 2026.
  • AUSTRAC — Pubs and Clubs with Gaming Machines Regulatory Guide, September 2026, pages 48–50.
  • Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act 2006 (Cth), particularly sections 26F, 26H and 233K.
  • Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Rules 2025, particularly section 5-10.

#CHDPartners #CIRT #RTO #WHS #WorkHealthAndSafety #Training #RiskManagement #SecurityAndSafetyCompliance #SME #SmallBusiness #MichaelHuggett #AUSTRAC #AMLCTFAnnualComplianceReports #AMLCTFCompliance #AMLCTF #AntiMoneyLaundering 

Previous Post
Contractor Management in Registered Clubs: Who Is Responsible When Maintenance Work Is Being Done?